Share this

Showing posts with label Christianity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Christianity. Show all posts

Saturday, 17 February 2018

Falling out of love with strategy: A fractal theological word crisis

A fractal tree based on Luke 9 & 10
I love a good strategy game, whether it be chess, Risk, Stronghold or StarCraft. But the thing that bothers me about most strategy games is that once you've won, all that you've built and all that you've worked for is of no further use. The winning strategist never gets to live in the world they have conquered. My strategic relationship to the Kingdom of God is different to that in so many ways.
Today, I had the joy of engaging in a challenging conversation with Rev Tom Stuckey (Former president of Methodist Conference) after hearing him talk about his new book ‘Singing the Lord’s song in a strange land’. He suggested that the Methodist Church had too many strategists. Even though I agreed with him on pretty much everything else he said, I have always felt that we have too few strategists. I have for some time considered myself a strategist. After some discussion, Tom suggested that perhaps we had a different idea of what strategy meant - and I think perhaps he was right.
The trouble with the word ‘strategy’ is that it implies that there is a top down plan to put into action. Strategy suggests to many people that someone is in charge; a captain, a general or perhaps a business manager. It is a word with its origins in ancient Greek military talk and has at the core of its meaning the deployment of troops to the battlefield. Whether for military or management speak, it is largely a word that is about taking control of the situation.
In addition to the usual problems with deploying military speak in a theological context, the more specific problem here is that strategy can be heard as something too practical, too linear and too hierarchical. It is too much about the straight line between where we are and where we intend to be. It has the potential to make us sound like we know where we are going – which we certainly do not.
Tom’s suggestion is that we need to stop domesticating God and trying to fit God into a neat box that fits our expectations; that we need to stop trying to be in control of what is, after all, God’s mission. Tom pointed out how the Methodist Church has become weighed down with bureaucracy. I agree to a great extent and I realise now that we need to find a language to speak more specifically and with more discernment than simply talking about 'strategy'. We have more than enough people pushing the metaphorical troops around the map.
Where I differ from Tom is that I think we need to be strategic about how we structure church. The one to one engagement between people is great and to a certain extent that is where the great moments of faith happen. However, when things are going well things will grow and systems will develop as they always have. In order to do the corporate, connexional thing well, we need to be able to engage with and discern how God is calling us to act together. When the systems grow so the imperfections of humanity become immortalised in the structures of our organisation.
I think we need strategy, or something with a different name, that speaks more of the abstract and the aspirational. We need patterns that help us to embody a more Christ-like nature and enact the Gospel narrative within our structures. I still want a strategy, in as much as I want a plan, but I have no intention of setting the destination, or of putting myself or anyone else in charge of getting us there. I want a plan that contains the essence of all we have learned collectively as ‘Church’. I want a plan that gives space for the diversity of humanity within the body of Christ. I want a plan that brings fluidity and life to our structures, and structures that reflect the living Gospel of Jesus Christ. I want a plan that admits we know nothing and frees us to fully submit to the mystery of God. 
This is why I believe we truly need a fractal understanding of God’s creation and of God’s plan for us. We need to be a fluid, organic system, growing in the image of our creator. We need to be bold enough to be more Christ-like in our corporate, collective, connexional way of being – but we need to do that in a way that leaves space for us to turn around when we’ve got it wrong. We need to be able to implement the theological learning we do on a daily basis, simply by being one of God’s creations, in the way that we function together as Church.
The fractal theological way of thinking is to see the patterns of God’s love and justice, echoed in us as individuals and at all scales of what we call Church – at all scales of human community and in our engagement with creation itself. The fractal theological way of thinking is not about a commander setting a destination for the troops, but about setting Christ-like patterns at the heart of who we are as community and as individuals - and allowing those patterns to shape who we become – allowing them to guide us to unknown destinations.
The only word I had to describe this kind of planning was strategy, but I suddenly feel like this word is no longer enough. So, what is the word I am looking for?

(N.B. I’ve not had time to read all of Tom’s book yet but what I’ve read so far looks very good – he describes it as dropping pebbles in the pond of the conversation and watching the ripples, rather than a book that gives the answers.  More about the book here: www.tomstuckey.me.uk/ )

Sunday, 1 May 2016

Breaking and pouring version 5: A Short Communion for a busy service



A Short Communion
|Breaking and pouring version 5: for a busy service|





Jesus and his disciples came to Jerusalem to celebrate the festival of Passover, where they remembered how, through God's guidance, Moses brought them out of captivity in Egypt, the sacrificial lambs were brought to the temple, because, in the time of the Exodus, the blood of lambs was used as a marker on the doors so that the angel of death would pass over those houses. 
As part of the celebration Jesus and his disciples joined together in a traditional meal in an upper room that they had hired for the occasion; a meal of thanksgiving for freedom
But their freedom was not complete; it was temporary and rooted in earthly promises.
A new promise was to be made there in that room by Jesus. Moses was only a man, speaking the words of God. But Jesus was God in human form;
And here in this place, just as Jesus did there in that upper room on the night before he died, we take the bread and we break it and share it amongst his disciples...
(The bread is broken)
...and he asked them as he asks us today to take this bread and eat it, and to imagine that this is his body which is being broken for you.
And in the days of Leviticus when the priests made animal sacrifices, the priests would say that no one should drink the blood, because it contained the spirit of the animal which, was poured out for the sins of the people. When Jesus offered himself as sacrifice on the cross, he declared an end to the sacrifice because his spirit was poured out for the forgiveness of all sins for all time. For this was not the spirit of one of God's creatures, but the spirit of God himself being poured out (The wine is poured from the one cup into another) and there in that upper room he poured out the wine as his spirit would be poured out to all people.
Knowing what was about to happen, at the end of the meal he took the cup gave thanks and gave it to his disciples, asking them to drink from it, as he asks us to drink from it today - and to imagine that this is his blood which was about to be poured out for you, to seal the new promise which God is making with all people.
This is God's spirit poured out for all.
May we be transformed in the breaking and in the pouring as we do this in remembrance of Jesus who awaits the opportunity to share this meal with us in the Kingdom of Heaven.
Come gather at the table for all who love the Lord and all who seek the lord and all who would allow themselves to be changed by God's love are welcome at this table.
Presider: Let us pray - 'There is a Jewish custom, at the end of such a meal to agree to meet again in Jerusalem next year at the Passover, Jesus said I am the vine you are the branches, he also said 'I won't share in the fruits of this vine until I see you again in the Kingdom.' Lord may your vine bear fruit in us, may your kingdom dwell in us and may we always meet with you when we share this meal together. Bless us as we go out from this place that we, broken and remade in your image, may carry the out pouring of your spirit to the streets and the fields.

Amen

Breaking and pouring version 4: Communion Service for Maundy Thursday (version 2)


Communion Service 
for Maundy Thursday

|Breaking and pouring version 4: for Maundy Thursday version 2|





Presider: Jesus and his disciples had come to Jerusalem to celebrate the festival of the Passover.
The Passover was a weeklong celebration in the capital city, where they remembered the time when, through God's guidance, Moses brought them out of captivity in Egypt, the sacrificial lambs were brought to the temple, because, in the time of the Exodus, the blood of lambs was used as a marker on the doors so that the angel of death would pass over those houses. 
As part of the celebration Jesus and his disciples joined together in a traditional meal in an upper room that they had hired for the occasion; a meal of thanksgiving for their freedom.
Raising the cup the presider says;
Let us raise the cup of freedom;
We proclaim good news to the poor;
Freedom for prisoners
A vision for those who have not seen,
And a lifting of the burdens of the oppressed
And so today we raise our thanks to the father of creation;
Thanks be to God, amen.
Song: STF 410 (H&P 774) Lord Your Church on Earth is Seeking

©Hugh Sherlock (1905-1998)

Lord, your Church on earth is seeking
your renewal from above;
teach us all the art of speaking
with the accent of your love.
We would heed your great commission:
sending us to every place —
preach, baptise, fulfil my mission,
serve with love and share my grace.

Freedom give to those in bondage,
lift the burdens caused by sin.
Give new hope, new strength and courage,
grant release from fears within:
light for darkness; joy for sorrow;
love for hatred; peace for strife.
These and countless blessings follow
as the Spirit gives new life.

In the streets of every city
where the bruised and lonely dwell,
let us show the Saviour’s pity,
let us of his mercy tell.
In all lands and with all races
let us serve, and seek to bring
all the world to render praises,
Christ, to you, Redeemer, King.

Presider: But their freedom was not complete; it was temporary and rooted in earthly promises.
A new promise was to be made there in that room by Jesus. Moses, great though he was, was only a man, speaking the words of God. But Jesus was God in human form;
And here in this place, just as Jesus did there in that upper room on the night before he died, we take the bread and we break it and share it amongst his disciples...
(The bread is broken and shared around the table)
...and he asked them as he asks us today to take this bread and eat it, and to imagine that this is his body which is being broken for you.
Sing (to the tune Hanover);
Presider: Are we now the Church, The body of Christ
The body, the bread, all gathered at once?
Will we let God break us, and take us apart
Remake our true image, reform us in love?

All: Yes we are the Church, The body of Christ
The body the bread, all gathered at once
We come to be broken, and taken apart
Remade in God's image, reformed in God's love
In the breaking of this bread; we are broken;
Like the body of Christ; we are broken
As we share in his self sacrifice; So we are remade in the image of God

We share together in the meal and the bread shared out becomes part of that meal. During the meal the following readings are read by various people;

Exodus 12:1-14 (NIV), Psalm 116:13-14 (NIV), 1 Corinthians 11:23-26 (NIV), Mark 14:23-26 (NIV), John 13:3-11, 15-17, 34 (NIV)

At the end of the meal the presider says;

In the days of Leviticus when the priests made animal sacrifices, the priests would say that no one should drink the blood, because it contained the spirit of the animal. The spirit of the animal was poured out for the sins of the people. When Jesus offered himself as sacrifice on the cross, he declared an end to the sacrifice because his spirit was poured out for the forgiveness of all sins for all time. For this was not the spirit of one of God's creatures, but the spirit of God himself being poured out for all people (The wine is poured from the central cup into individual cups) and there in that upper room he poured out the wine as his spirit would be poured out to all people.
As we hand around the cups, sing (to the tune Hanover);
Presider: The spirit of God poured out to the world
An unending gift, the cup that we share
The cleansing and healing, forgiveness and life
Abundantly poured out beyond these four walls
All: The spirit of God we gladly receive
An unending gift, this cup is for all
The cleansing and healing, forgiveness and life
We share in outpouring God's love to the world
Knowing what was about to happen, at the end of the meal he took the cup gave thanks and gave it to his disciples, asking them to drink from it, as he asks us to drink from it today - and as you do, imagine that this is his blood which was about to be poured out for you, to seal the new promise which God is making with all people.
This is God's spirit poured out for all.
It is freely poured out for the forgiveness of sins. Amen
We all drink from the cups.
And Jesus told them to do this whenever they met to remember him. Do what, I wonder?
Well John tells us that after the meal Jesus washed their feet, and insisted that they washed each other's feet, a humble act of service. It is above all things our call to serve each other as Christ has served us and to serve those who have not yet known Christ, just as once we did not know Christ.
We serve each other and the world in the breaking and in the pouring.
We do this in remembrance of Jesus
We do this in remembrance of Jesus who awaits the opportunity to share this meal with us in the Kingdom of Heaven.
Song: STF 272 (CMP 162) From heaven you came

© Graham Kendrick 1983

From heaven you came, helpless babe,
Entered our world, your glory veiled;
Not to be served but to serve,
And give your life that we might live.

            This is our God, the Servant King,
            He calls us now to follow him,
            To bring our lives as a daily offering
            Of worship to the Servant King.

There in the garden of tears,
My heavy load he chose to bear;
His heart with sorrow was torn,
'Yet not my will but yours,' he said.

Come, see his hands and his feet,
The scars that speak of sacrifice,
Hands that flung stars into space
To cruel nails surrendered.

So let us learn how to serve,
 And in our lives enthrone him;
 Each other's needs to prefer,
 For it is Christ we're serving.

Presider: It may well have been customary to end such a meal with the agreement to meet again in Jerusalem next year at the Passover, but having previously told them that he was the vine and they were his branches, he simply said 'I won't have the chance to share in the fruits of this vine until I see you again in the Kingdom.'

Until we meet again, amen.

We all leave in silence

Monday, 24 February 2014

Science and Religion - Changing the story from conflict to harmony

            I have recently been learning about the relationship between science and theology with Rev Prof David Wilkinson, and the thing that most struck me about what I have studied so far is the extent to which faith plays a fundamental part in the construct of science. I am not suggesting that you need to be a Christian to be a scientist or that all scientists are secretly religious, although many scientists do have a religious faith. No, the suggestion I am making is far more simple and far more specific than that. In order to study science you need to have an inherent belief that the world makes sense, that it is comprehensible, otherwise experiments wouldn't be repeatable and theories wouldn't be provable.
            It is the presumption of science that something which is true here is also true on a planet that spins around a distant star, even though none of us has ever been there to test out such a theory; and it is the presumption of science that something that is true today will also be true tomorrow. As none of us have yet been to tomorrow we cannot be certain that anything we know to be true today will still be true tomorrow. In many ways the assumption of science is not a wild one; yesterday we thought that the rules of physics would be the same today and so it is not unreasonable to assume that the same will still be true tomorrow, and if gravity and light can be observed doing the same things to a distant planet, as they do to our own then we can make a healthy guess that things work the same there as they do here.
            But there are two interesting points to be made here. The first is that this concept of the world being comprehensible comes historically from religious ideas that influenced the birth of science and so the idea that science and religion are at odds is really quite a modern story. The second is the interesting idea that although both Christian theology and Science have a concept of a comprehensible universe, both also have areas where mystery and incompatible realities take the fore. This can be seen in theological issues such as miracles and the nature of God's incarnation in Christ. Likewise with science there are strange incompatibilities between the way things function at the tiny quantum level and how they work at the cosmic level of astrophysics. There are mysteries in science like the question of whether light is a wave or a particle, and even whether uncertainty is an intrinsic part of the sub atomic world. But in both areas of study it is these mysteries that lead us to push forward in our exploration and seek to discover more.
            In the course of my studies I have found myself looking more deeply into the arguments of Richard Dawkins, and whilst he is a great biologist I realise that his arguments against religion come entirely from a prejudged view of religion as intrinsically bad, and he does this without ever requiring himself to produce the empirical data that he is expecting from others. At a basic level he never even reconciles that theology and religion are as different as scientists and people who use toasters. But I am realising more and more that the flawed nature of his arguments is not what worries me most; it is their divisiveness.
            I think the most useful thing that Dawkins offers this generation is that he highlights the way that many of those gullible enough to be convinced by poorly formulated forms of religion are just as easily convinced by his distracting mixture of science, pseudo science and scientism. The conclusion that the Church perhaps ought to take from this is that we should no longer sit back and politely accept ill-informed theologies and ecclesiologies, but rather seek to challenge them with a sense of maturity, diplomacy and grace. In short, we need to do religion better. We can only hope that inasmuch as he draws the gullible to accept his spurious arguments, he will also encourage the curious to ask deeper questions about his assertions. The worst thing that Dawkins has brought to this generation is yet another poorly formed religion and a descent into the kind of dogmatic conflict that he himself claims to abhor. 
            However, I have also found myself looking at the history of what we now call 'creationism'. And I have learned that the word was not used to describe people who believed in a seven day creation or those who oppose evolution until 1929 in a book called 'Back to Creationism' by Harold Clark, a little known biology teacher from California. What follows this book is a tale of divisive theological arguments, that were neither great theology, nor great science. They came from an ever expanding minority of fundamentalists that would eventually spread beyond America and even to some extent beyond Christianity, into Judaism and Islam.
            I find myself quite angered now by the way that fundamentalists on both sides of the science and religion argument have hijacked the concept and the language of creation and made it into a wedge to drive between groups of human beings who never should have been enemies. So perhaps we ought to spend more time together in harmony with scientists simply marvelling at the mysterious wonder of God's creation and sharing our stories with each other.